The Senate Working Log, noting its historical adherence to its古怪 procedures, ruled that several key aspects of the proposed "Big Beautiful Bill" violate the Byrd Rule, a Senate procedural rule designed to moderate spending and revenue issues. Specifically, the bill cannot be included in the upcoming budget reconciliation bill because it would require the Senate to obtain 60 votes to pass.
According to a press release from the Senate Budget Committee ranking member, the changes to student loan repayment plans, such as altering the loan repayment process for existing borrowers, would require 60 votes to pass and could not be included in the bill. Similarly, the proposed modifications to PSLF eligibility for medical residents would bar them from qualifying as employment in residency, which could block many medical institutions from receiving federal support under the Workforce Pell Program. Expanded Pell Grants to unaccredited institutions and for-profit employers would also violate Byrd Rule—a six-part rule that ensures provisions are relevant to government spending, do not disproportionately affect previous debts, and do not extend beyond a ten-year deficit period. These changes would therefore be blocked from being included in the bill as proposed.
While the Senate parliamentarian’s stance isn’t binding, it remains significant for current student loan borrowers. The rules would likely override existing legal rights and apply to current borrowers in a way that is not tied to the upcoming vote. As such, changes to the Repayment Assistance Plan would still be enacted for future borrowers, starting in 2026. However, any changes to the Repayment Assistance Plan would still need a 60-vote majority in the Senate, reflecting a broader shift in budget reconciliation priorities.
The Byrd Rule is a Senate procedural rule that limits what can be included in a budget reconciliation bill. It primarily restricts provisions that do not primarily impact government authority, do not disproportionately affect existing debts, and do not extend beyond a ten-year deficit. Additionally, the rule prohibits extraneous matter, which the压销售收入 is defined by the parliamentarian’s criteria and third-party […]年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年份年 diffs cannot be included in the budget reconciliation because of the key to add 60 votes. différentdoman_gene SE asks that provision: changes fly to 60 votes into feet must be reconsidered to 1-year old borrowing requirements plus the download rules.
According to the transcript, the slope adjustments likely meet the majority or might not meet the rule requirements, depending on the provisions.
Differential rule analysis shows that unless the input provisions are entirely zero,бан ability or a similar factor, etc., the rule must be met against some or.
